Swiftorial Logo
Home
Swift Lessons
Matchups
CodeSnaps
Tutorials
Career
Resources

Embedding vs Referencing in MongoDB

1. Introduction

In MongoDB, data modeling is crucial for effective database design. Two primary strategies for data modeling are embedding and referencing. This lesson breaks down these concepts, providing clarity on when to use each approach.

2. Embedding

2.1 What is Embedding?

Embedding involves storing related data within a single document. This method is beneficial for data that is frequently accessed together.

For example, if you have a blog post and its comments, you might embed comments within the blog post document:

{
    "_id": 1,
    "title": "My First Blog Post",
    "content": "Hello, world!",
    "comments": [
        { "user": "Alice", "message": "Great post!" },
        { "user": "Bob", "message": "Thanks for sharing!" }
    ]
}

2.2 Advantages of Embedding

  • Improved read performance by reducing the number of database operations.
  • Data integrity since related data is stored together.

2.3 Disadvantages of Embedding

  • Document size limit (16MB). Large data sets may lead to issues.
  • Data redundancy if the same embedded document is used in multiple locations.

3. Referencing

3.1 What is Referencing?

Referencing involves storing related data in separate documents and using references (IDs) to connect them. This approach is beneficial for data that is less frequently accessed together.

For example, you might store blog posts and comments in separate collections:

{
    "_id": 1,
    "title": "My First Blog Post",
    "content": "Hello, world!"
}

{
    "_id": 1,
    "postId": 1,
    "user": "Alice",
    "message": "Great post!"
}

3.2 Advantages of Referencing

  • Reduction of data redundancy, making updates easier.
  • Ability to handle large datasets without hitting document size limits.

3.3 Disadvantages of Referencing

  • More complex queries involving joins (lookups).
  • Potentially lower read performance due to multiple database operations.

4. Best Practices

When deciding between embedding and referencing, consider the following:

  • Use embedding when:
    • Data is frequently accessed together.
    • Data is relatively small and does not grow unbounded.
  • Use referencing when:
    • Data is large or grows unbounded.
    • Data is accessed independently or shared across multiple documents.

5. Flowchart


graph TD;
    A[Is data frequently accessed together?] -->|Yes| B[Use Embedding];
    A -->|No| C[Is data large or grows unbounded?];
    C -->|Yes| D[Use Referencing];
    C -->|No| B;

6. FAQ

Q1: Can I mix embedding and referencing?

A1: Yes, it's common to use both strategies within the same application, depending on the specific requirements of different data types.

Q2: What happens if I exceed the document size limit with embedding?

A2: If you exceed the 16MB limit, you will need to refactor your data model to use referencing or reduce the size of embedded documents.

Q3: How do I decide which method to use?

A3: Analyze your application's data access patterns, size, and redundancy needs to make an informed decision.